Optimizing Truffle Interpreters

This document discusses tools for optimizing or debugging Truffle interpreters for peak temporal performance.

Strategy #

  1. Run with a profiler to sample the application and identify responsible compilation units. Use a sampling delay (--cpusampler.Delay=MILLISECONDS) to only profile after warmup. See the Profiling guide.

  2. Understand what is being compiled and look for deoptimizations. Methods that are listed to run mostly in the interpreter likely have a problem with deoptimization.

  3. Simplify the code as much as possible where it still shows the performance problem.

  4. Enable performance warnings and list boundary calls.

  5. Dump the Graal graph of the responsible compilation unit and look at the phase After TruffleTier.
    1. Look at the Graal graphs at the phases After TruffleTier and After PartialEscape and check if it is what you would expect. If there are nodes there that you don’t want to be there, think about how to guard against including them. If there are more complex nodes there than you want, think about how to add specialisations that generate simpler code. If there are nodes you think should be there in a benchmark that are not, think about how to make values dynamic so they are not optimized away.
  6. Search for Invoke nodes in the Graal IR. Invoke nodes that are not representing guest language calls should be specialized away. This may not be always possible, e.g., if the method does I/O.

  7. Search for control flow splits (red lines) and investigate whether they result from control flow caused by the guest application or are just artifacts from the language implementation. The latter should be avoided if possible.

  8. Search for indirections in linear code (Load and LoadIndexed) and try to minimize the code. The less code that is on the hot-path the better.

Truffle Compiler Options #

A full list of the latest expert and internal options can be found in the Options guide.

Observing Compilations #

This section provides an overview of most of the available command line options to observe compilations.

Note: Most options also require the additional --experimental-options flag set.

The --engine.TraceCompilation command prints a line each time a method is compiled:

[engine] opt done   id=244   EqualityConstraint.execute                         |Tier 1|Time   268( 220+47  )ms|AST   17|Inlined   0Y   2N|IR    238/   437|CodeSize    1874|Timestamp 758868036671903|Src octane-deltablue.js:528

Here is a quick overview of the information provided in these logs:

  • id - Unique identifier of the call target.
  • Tier - For which compilation tier was the targed scheduled.
  • Time - How long did the compilation last, with separation between the Truffle tier (mainly partial evaluation) and the Graal Tiers.
  • AST - The targets non-trivial node count.
  • Inlined - How many calls were inlined and how many remained calls after inlining.
  • IR - Graal node count after partial evaluation and after compilation.
  • CodeSize - The size of the code generated for the call target.
  • Timestamp - The time when the event happened as reported by System.nanoTime().
  • Src - Abbreviated source section of the call target.

The --engine.TraceCompilationDetails command prints a line when compilation is queued, unqueued, started, or completed:

[engine] opt queued id=237   BinaryConstraint.output                            |Tier 1|Count/Thres         25/       25|Queue: Size    1 Change +1  Load  0.06 Time     0us|Timestamp 758865671350686|Src octane-deltablue.js:416
[engine] opt start  id=237   BinaryConstraint.output                            |Tier 1|Priority        25|Rate 0.000000|Queue: Size    0 Change +0  Load  0.06 Time     0us|Timestamp 758865708273384|Src octane-deltablue.js:416
[engine] opt queued id=239   OrderedCollection.size                             |Tier 1|Count/Thres         25/       25|Queue: Size    1 Change +1  Load  0.06 Time     0us|Timestamp 758865727664193|Src octane-deltablue.js:71
[engine] opt queued id=52    Array.prototype.push                               |Tier 1|Count/Thres         25/       50|Queue: Size    2 Change +1  Load  0.13 Time     0us|Timestamp 758865744191674|Src <builtin>:1
... more log ...
[engine] opt start  id=239   OrderedCollection.size                             |Tier 1|Priority    181875|Rate 0.000001|Queue: Size   11 Change -1  Load  0.63 Time   575us|Timestamp 758866381654116|Src octane-deltablue.js:71
[engine] opt done   id=237   BinaryConstraint.output                            |Tier 1|Time   717( 654+64  )ms|AST   19|Inlined   0Y   0N|IR    143/   220|CodeSize     882|Timestamp 758866435391354|Src octane-deltablue.js:416
[engine] opt start  id=236   BinaryConstraint.input                             |Tier 1|Priority    144000|Rate 0.000001|Queue: Size   10 Change -1  Load  0.56 Time    48us|Timestamp 758866452554530|Src octane-deltablue.js:409
... more log ...
[engine] opt queued id=239   OrderedCollection.size                             |Tier 2|Count/Thres       8750/     8125|Queue: Size   18 Change +1  Load  0.81 Time     0us|Timestamp 758867756295139|Src octane-deltablue.js:71
[engine] opt queued id=237   BinaryConstraint.output                            |Tier 2|Count/Thres       8499/     8750|Queue: Size   19 Change +1  Load  0.88 Time     0us|Timestamp 758867758263099|Src octane-deltablue.js:416
[engine] opt start  id=244   EqualityConstraint.execute                         |Tier 1|Priority   2618289|Rate 0.000015|Queue: Size   19 Change -1  Load  0.88 Time   180us|Timestamp 758867767116908|Src octane-deltablue.js:528
... more log ...
[engine] opt done   id=246   OrderedCollection.at                               |Tier 2|Time    89(  80+9   )ms|AST   15|Inlined   0Y   0N|IR     50/   110|CodeSize     582|Timestamp 758873628915755|Src octane-deltablue.js:67
[engine] opt start  id=237   BinaryConstraint.output                            |Tier 2|Priority    173536|Rate 0.000054|Queue: Size   18 Change -1  Load  0.94 Time    18us|Timestamp 758873629411012|Src octane-deltablue.js:416
[engine] opt queued id=238   Planner.addPropagate                               |Tier 2|Count/Thres       9375/     8750|Queue: Size   19 Change +1  Load  0.88 Time     0us|Timestamp 758873663196884|Src octane-deltablue.js:696
[engine] opt queued id=226   Variable.addConstraint                             |Tier 2|Count/Thres       8771/     9375|Queue: Size   20 Change +1  Load  0.94 Time     0us|Timestamp 758873665823697|Src octane-deltablue.js:556
[engine] opt done   id=293   change                                             |Tier 1|Time   167( 130+37  )ms|AST   60|Inlined   0Y   6N|IR    576/  1220|CodeSize    5554|Timestamp 758873669483749|Src octane-deltablue.js:867
[engine] opt start  id=270   Plan.execute                                       |Tier 2|Priority    157871|Rate 0.000072|Queue: Size   19 Change -1  Load  1.00 Time    17us|Timestamp 758873669912101|Src octane-deltablue.js:778
[engine] opt done   id=237   BinaryConstraint.output                            |Tier 2|Time    58(  52+6   )ms|AST   19|Inlined   0Y   0N|IR    103/   181|CodeSize     734|Timestamp 758873687678394|Src octane-deltablue.js:416
... more log ...
[engine] opt unque. id=304   Date.prototype.valueOf                             |Tier 2|Count/Thres      80234/     3125|Queue: Size    4 Change  0  Load  0.31 Time     0us|Timestamp 758899904132076|Src <builtin>:1|Reason Target inlined into only caller

Here is a quick overview of the information added in these logs:

  • Count/Thres - What is the call and loop count of the target and what is the threshold needed to add the compilation to the queue.
  • Queue: Size - How many compilations are in the compilation queue.
  • Queue: Change - How did this event impact the compilation queue (e.g. certain events can prune the queue of unneeded compilation tasks).
  • Queue: Load - A metric of whether the queue is over/under loaded. Normal load is represented with 1, less then 1 is underloaded and greater than 1 is overloaded.
  • Queue: Time - How long did the event take.
  • Reason - The runtime reported reason for the event.

The --engine.TraceCompilationAST command prints the Truffle AST for each compilation:

[engine] opt AST          OrderedCollection.size <split-57429b3a>                     |ASTSize      10/   10 |Calls/Thres   10559/    3 |CallsAndLoop/Thres   10559/ 1000
  FunctionRootNode
    body = FunctionBodyNode
      body = DualNode
        left = JSWriteCurrentFrameSlotNodeGen
          rhsNode = JSPrepareThisNodeGen
            operandNode = AccessThisNode
        right = TerminalPositionReturnNode
          expression = PropertyNode
            target = PropertyNode
              target = JSReadCurrentFrameSlotNodeGen
              cache = PropertyGetNode
                cacheNode = ObjectPropertyGetNode
                  receiverCheck = ShapeCheckNode
            cache = PropertyGetNode
              cacheNode = ArrayLengthPropertyGetNode
                receiverCheck = ShapeCheckNode
                arrayLengthRead = ArrayLengthReadNodeGen

The --engine.TraceInlining command prints guest-language inlining decisions for each compilation:

[engine] inline start     Plan.execute                                                |call diff        0.00 |Recursion Depth      0 |Explore/inline ratio     1.00 |IR Nodes         2704 |Frequency        1.00 |Truffle Callees      5 |Forced          false |Depth               0
[engine] Inlined            Plan.size                                                 |call diff     -203.75 |Recursion Depth      0 |Explore/inline ratio      NaN |IR Nodes          175 |Frequency      101.88 |Truffle Callees      1 |Forced          false |Depth               1
[engine] Inlined              OrderedCollection.size <split-e13c02e>                  |call diff     -101.88 |Recursion Depth      0 |Explore/inline ratio      NaN |IR Nodes          157 |Frequency      101.88 |Truffle Callees      0 |Forced          false |Depth               2
[engine] Inlined            Plan.constraintAt                                         |call diff     -201.75 |Recursion Depth      0 |Explore/inline ratio      NaN |IR Nodes          206 |Frequency      100.88 |Truffle Callees      1 |Forced          false |Depth               1
[engine] Inlined              OrderedCollection.at                                    |call diff     -100.88 |Recursion Depth      0 |Explore/inline ratio      NaN |IR Nodes          232 |Frequency      100.88 |Truffle Callees      0 |Forced          false |Depth               2
[engine] Inlined            ScaleConstraint.execute                                   |call diff       -0.00 |Recursion Depth      0 |Explore/inline ratio      NaN |IR Nodes          855 |Frequency        0.00 |Truffle Callees      0 |Forced          false |Depth               1
[engine] Inlined            EqualityConstraint.execute                                |call diff     -299.63 |Recursion Depth      0 |Explore/inline ratio      NaN |IR Nodes          295 |Frequency       99.88 |Truffle Callees      2 |Forced          false |Depth               1
[engine] Inlined              BinaryConstraint.output <split-1e163df7>                |call diff      -99.88 |Recursion Depth      0 |Explore/inline ratio      NaN |IR Nodes          259 |Frequency       99.88 |Truffle Callees      0 |Forced          false |Depth               2
[engine] Inlined              BinaryConstraint.input <split-2dfade22>                 |call diff      -99.88 |Recursion Depth      0 |Explore/inline ratio      NaN |IR Nodes          259 |Frequency       99.88 |Truffle Callees      0 |Forced          false |Depth               2
[engine] Inlined            EditConstraint.execute                                    |call diff       -1.00 |Recursion Depth      0 |Explore/inline ratio      NaN |IR Nodes           22 |Frequency        1.00 |Truffle Callees      0 |Forced          false |Depth               1
[engine] inline done      Plan.execute                                                |call diff        0.00 |Recursion Depth      0 |Explore/inline ratio     1.00 |IR Nodes         2704 |Frequency        1.00 |Truffle Callees      5 |Forced          false |Depth               0

The --engine.TraceSplitting command prints guest-language splitting decisions:

[engine] split   0-4310d43-1     Strength                                                    |ASTSize       6/    6 |Calls/Thres       2/    3 |CallsAndLoop/Thres       2/ 1000 |SourceSection /Users/christianhumer/graal/4dev/js-benchmarks/octane-deltablue.js~139:4062-4089
[engine] split   1-4b0d79fc-1     Strength                                                    |ASTSize       6/    6 |Calls/Thres       2/    3 |CallsAndLoop/Thres       2/ 1000 |SourceSection /Users/christianhumer/graal/4dev/js-benchmarks/octane-deltablue.js~140:4119-4150

The --engine.TracePerformanceWarnings=(call|instanceof|store|all) command prints code which may not be ideal for performance. The call enables warnings when partial evaluation cannot inline the virtual runtime call. The instanceof enables warnings when partial evaluation cannot resolve virtual instanceof to an exact type. The store enables warnings when the store location argument is not a partial evaluation constant:

[engine] perf warn        ScaleConstraint.execute                                     |Partial evaluation could not inline the virtual runtime call Virtual to HotSpotMethod<ConditionProfile.profile(boolean)> (167|MethodCallTarget).
  Approximated stack trace for [167 | MethodCallTarget:    at com.oracle.truffle.js.nodes.control.IfNode.execute(IfNode.java:158)
    at com.oracle.truffle.js.nodes.binary.DualNode.execute(DualNode.java:125)
    at com.oracle.truffle.js.nodes.function.FunctionBodyNode.execute(FunctionBodyNode.java:73)
    at com.oracle.truffle.js.nodes.function.FunctionRootNode.executeInRealm(FunctionRootNode.java:147)
    at com.oracle.truffle.js.runtime.JavaScriptRealmBoundaryRootNode.execute(JavaScriptRealmBoundaryRootNode.java:93)
    at org.graalvm.compiler.truffle.runtime.OptimizedCallTarget.executeRootNode(OptimizedCallTarget.java:503)
    at org.graalvm.compiler.truffle.runtime.OptimizedCallTarget.profiledPERoot(OptimizedCallTarget.java:480)

The --engine.CompilationStatistics command prints statistics on compilations at the end of the process:

[engine] Truffle runtime statistics for engine 1
    Compilations                : 2763
      Success                   : 2743
      Temporary Bailouts        : 17
        org.graalvm.compiler.core.common.CancellationBailoutException: Compilation cancelled.: 16
        org.graalvm.compiler.core.common.RetryableBailoutException: Assumption invalidated while compiling code: IsolatedObjectConstant[Object]: 1
      Permanent Bailouts        : 0
      Failed                    : 0
      Interrupted               : 3
    Invalidated                 : 84
        Unknown Reason          : 45
        Profiled Argument Types : 22
        validRootAssumption Split call node: 12
        expression invalidatePropertyAssumption: 1
        getTextPos invalidatePropertyAssumption: 1
        X_OK invalidateAllPropertyAssumptions: 1
        statements invalidatePropertyAssumption: 1
        typed object location generalizing object type !class com.oracle.truffle.js.runtime.objects.Nullish => !class java.lang.Object Object@0[final=false][type=class com.oracle.truffle.js.runtime.objects.Nullish]: 1
    Queues                      : 3410
    Dequeues                    : 262
        Split call node         : 124
        Target inlined into only caller: 87
        validRootAssumption Split call node: 28
        null                    : 17
        Profiled Argument Types : 6
    Splits                      : 5581
    Compilation Accuracy        : 0,969598
    Queue Accuracy              : 0,923167
    Compilation Utilization     : 2,685016
    Remaining Compilation Queue : 409
    Time to queue               : count=3410, sum=12895957640, min=       0, average=  3781805,76, max=11311217, maxTarget=Math.floor
    Time waiting in queue       : count=2763, sum=1247424699, min=      40, average=   451474,74, max= 4762017, maxTarget=tryGetTypeFromEffectiveTypeNode
  ---------------------------   :
  AST node statistics           :
    Truffle node count          : count=2752, sum=    348085, min=       1, average=      126,48, max=    5404, maxTarget=checkSignatureDeclaration
      Trivial                   : count=2752, sum=    124817, min=       0, average=       45,36, max=    2707, maxTarget=visitEachChild
      Non Trivial               : count=2752, sum=    223268, min=       1, average=       81,13, max=    3162, maxTarget=checkSignatureDeclaration
        Monomorphic             : count=2752, sum=    217660, min=       1, average=       79,09, max=    3042, maxTarget=checkSignatureDeclaration
        Polymorphic             : count=2752, sum=      4239, min=       0, average=        1,54, max=      71, maxTarget=checkSignatureDeclaration
        Megamorphic             : count=2752, sum=      1369, min=       0, average=        0,50, max=      49, maxTarget=checkSignatureDeclaration
    Truffle call count          : count=2752, sum=      7789, min=       0, average=        2,83, max=     110, maxTarget=forEachChild
      Indirect                  : count=2752, sum=        29, min=       0, average=        0,01, max=       3, maxTarget=emitLeadingComments
      Direct                    : count=2752, sum=      7760, min=       0, average=        2,82, max=     110, maxTarget=forEachChild
        Dispatched              : count=2752, sum=      6285, min=       0, average=        2,28, max=     110, maxTarget=forEachChild
        Inlined                 : count=2752, sum=      1475, min=       0, average=        0,54, max=      60, maxTarget=parseList <split-8113>
        ----------              :
        Cloned                  : count=2752, sum=         0, min=       0, average=        0,00, max=       0, maxTarget=Array.prototype.push
        Not Cloned              : count=2752, sum=      7747, min=       0, average=        2,82, max=     110, maxTarget=forEachChild
    Truffle loops               : count=2752, sum=       723, min=       0, average=        0,26, max=      12, maxTarget=pipelineEmitWithComments
  ---------------------------   :
  Compilation Tier 1            :
    Compilation Rate            :    471075,74 bytes/second
    Truffle Tier Rate           :   1273853,94 bytes/second
    Graal Tier Rate             :    922948,70 bytes/second
    Installation Rate           :   5640071,94 bytes/second
    Time for compilation (us)   : count=2637, sum=  20538922, min=     727, average=     7788,75, max= 2154173, maxTarget=createPrinter
      Truffle Tier (us)         : count=2623, sum=   7595366, min=     255, average=     2895,68, max=  306107, maxTarget=createPrinter
      Graal Tier (us)           : count=2623, sum=  10483126, min=     378, average=     3996,62, max= 1665018, maxTarget=createPrinter
      Code Installation (us)    : count=2623, sum=   1715472, min=      39, average=      654,01, max=  183048, maxTarget=createPrinter
    Graal node count            :
      After Truffle Tier        : count=2627, sum=   1089218, min=      88, average=      414,62, max=   12999, maxTarget=forEachChild
      After Graal Tier          : count=2624, sum=   2190826, min=     127, average=      834,92, max=   63837, maxTarget=createPrinter
    Graal compilation result    :
      Code size                 : count=2623, sum=   9675388, min=     492, average=     3688,67, max=  238448, maxTarget=createPrinter
      Total frame size          : count=2623, sum=    350080, min=      64, average=      133,47, max=    5328, maxTarget=createPrinter
      Exception handlers        : count=2623, sum=      9316, min=       1, average=        3,55, max=     125, maxTarget=forEachChild
      Infopoints                : count=2623, sum=    105619, min=       5, average=       40,27, max=    1837, maxTarget=forEachChild
        CALL                    : count=2623, sum=    105619, min=       5, average=       40,27, max=    1837, maxTarget=forEachChild
    Marks                       : count=2623, sum=     13115, min=       5, average=        5,00, max=       5, maxTarget=Array.prototype.push
    Data references             : count=2623, sum=    185670, min=       9, average=       70,79, max=    4153, maxTarget=createPrinter
  ---------------------------   :
  Compilation Tier 2            :
    Compilation Rate            :    141825,62 bytes/second
    Truffle Tier Rate           :    397107,38 bytes/second
    Graal Tier Rate             :    243094,58 bytes/second
    Installation Rate           :   4122848,22 bytes/second
    Time for compilation (us)   : count= 123, sum=  11418247, min=     745, average=    92831,28, max=  456707, maxTarget=checkSignatureDeclaration
      Truffle Tier (us)         : count= 120, sum=   4077990, min=     288, average=    33983,25, max=  152158, maxTarget=WhileNode$WhileDoRepeatingNode@72d2eaac typescript-polybench.js:16129~ 'utf8ToBytes'<OSR>
      Graal Tier (us)           : count= 120, sum=   6661604, min=     310, average=    55513,37, max=  343028, maxTarget=checkSignatureDeclaration
      Code Installation (us)    : count= 120, sum=    392786, min=      42, average=     3273,22, max=   68576, maxTarget=JSArrayBufferView.@52bcd02
    Graal node count            :
      After Truffle Tier        : count= 125, sum=    331695, min=      13, average=     2653,56, max=   11989, maxTarget=checkSignatureDeclaration
      After Graal Tier          : count= 120, sum=    432639, min=      46, average=     3605,33, max=   19199, maxTarget=checkSignatureDeclaration
    Graal compilation result    :
      Code size                 : count= 120, sum=   1619400, min=     192, average=    13495,00, max=   72744, maxTarget=checkSignatureDeclaration
      Total frame size          : count= 120, sum=     25728, min=      48, average=      214,40, max=     768, maxTarget=bindEach <split-2459>
      Exception handlers        : count= 120, sum=      1080, min=       0, average=        9,00, max=      84, maxTarget=checkSignatureDeclaration
      Infopoints                : count= 120, sum=      7236, min=       3, average=       60,30, max=     401, maxTarget=checkSignatureDeclaration
        CALL                    : count= 120, sum=      7236, min=       3, average=       60,30, max=     401, maxTarget=checkSignatureDeclaration
    Marks                       : count= 120, sum=      1116, min=       5, average=        9,30, max=      35, maxTarget=checkIndexConstraintForProperty
    Data references             : count= 120, sum=     25252, min=       4, average=      210,43, max=    1369, maxTarget=checkSignatureDeclaration

The --engine.CompilationStatisticDetails command prints histogram information on individual Graal nodes in addition to the previous compilation statistics:

  Graal nodes after Truffle tier                    :
      FrameState                                    : count= 168, sum=   35502, min=       1, average=      211.32, max=    2048, maxTarget=deltaBlue
      FixedGuardNode                                : count= 168, sum=   18939, min=       0, average=      112.73, max=    1048, maxTarget=change
      LoadFieldNode                                 : count= 168, sum=   14432, min=       0, average=       85.90, max=     814, maxTarget=EditConstraint
      ...
  Graal nodes after Graal tier                      :
      BeginNode                                     : count= 166, sum=   33333, min=       0, average=      200.80, max=    2110, maxTarget=change
      FrameState                                    : count= 166, sum=   30591, min=       0, average=      184.28, max=    2393, maxTarget=MeasureDefault
      AMD64AddressNode                              : count= 166, sum=   20072, min=       0, average=      120.92, max=    1960, maxTarget=MeasureDefault
      ...

The --engine.TraceMethodExpansion=truffleTier command prints a tree of all expanded Java methods with statistics after each compilation:

[engine] Expansion tree for test after truffleTier:
Name                                                                                Frequency | Count    Size  Cycles   Ifs Loops Invokes Allocs | Self Count  Size Cycles   Ifs Loops Invokes Allocs | IRNode ASTNode Lang:File:Line:Chars
<root>                                                                                   1.00 |    64      72      42     1     1       0      1 |         34    20      0     0     0       0      0 |  -
 OptimizedCallTarget.profiledPERoot(Object)                                              1.00 |    30      52      42     1     1       0      1 |          1     2      2     0     0       0      0 |    121
  OptimizedCallTarget.injectArgumentsProfile(Object)                                     1.00 |     9      19      16     0     0       0      0 |          4     3      0     0     0       0      0 |      5
   OptimizedCallTarget.unsafeCast(Object, Class, Z, Z, Z)                                1.00 |     1       0       0     0     0       0      0 |          1     0      0     0     0       0      0 |     10
   OptimizedCallTarget.castArgumentsImpl(Object, Class)                                  1.00 |     4      16      16     0     0       0      0 |          4    16     16     0     0       0      0 |     12
  OptimizedCallTarget.executeRootNode(VirtualFrame)                                      1.00 |    20      31      24     1     1       0      1 |          0     0      0     0     0       0      0 |
   JavaScriptRealmBoundaryRootNode.execute(VirtualFrame)                                 1.00 |    20      31      24     1     1       0      1 |          1     1      0     0     0       0      0 |     34       0 js:test.js:1:0-100
    JavaScriptRealmBoundaryRootNode.getRealm()                                           1.00 |     1       1       0     0     0       0      0 |          0     0      0     0     0       0      0 |              0 js:test.js:1:0-100
     JSContext.getRealm()                                                                1.00 |     1       1       0     0     0       0      0 |          0     0      0     0     0       0      0 |
      PolyglotReferences$AssumeSingleContext.get()                                       1.00 |     1       1       0     0     0       0      0 |          0     0      0     0     0       0      0 |
       PolyglotReferences$WeakSingleContext.get()                                        1.00 |     1       1       0     0     0       0      0 |          1     1      0     0     0       0      0 |     37
    FunctionRootNode.executeInRealm(VirtualFrame)                                        1.00 |    18      29      24     1     1       0      1 |          1     1      0     0     0       0      0 |     41       0 js:test.js:1:0-100
     FunctionBodyNode.execute(VirtualFrame)                                              1.00 |    17      28      24     1     1       0      1 |          0     0      0     0     0       0      0 |              1 js:test.js:1:0-100
      AbstractBlockNode.execute(VirtualFrame)                                            1.00 |    17      28      24     1     1       0      1 |          0     0      0     0     0       0      0 |
       AbstractBlockNode.executeVoid(VirtualFrame, JavaScriptNode, I, I)                 1.00 |    16      20      16     1     1       0      0 |          1     1      0     0     0       0      0 |     50       2 js:test.js:1:16-100
        WhileNode.executeVoid(VirtualFrame)                                              1.00 |    15      19      16     1     1       0      0 |          0     0      0     0     0       0      0 |              7 js:test.js:3:35-84
         OptimizedOSRLoopNode.execute(VirtualFrame)                                    101.00 |    15      19      16     1     1       0      0 |          4     3      2     0     1       0      0 |     46       8 js:test.js:3:35-84
          RepeatingNode.executeRepeatingWithValue(VirtualFrame)                          1.00 |    11      16      14     1     0       0      0 |          1     1      0     0     0       0      0 |    100       9 js:test.js:3:35-84
           WhileNode$WhileDoRepeatingNode.executeRepeating(VirtualFrame)               101.00 |    10      15      14     1     0       0      0 |          3     2      1     1     0       0      0 |     63       9 js:test.js:3:35-84
            AbstractRepeatingNode.executeCondition(VirtualFrame)                       101.00 |     1       1       1     0     0       0      0 |          0     0      0     0     0       0      0 |              9 js:test.js:3:35-84
             StatementNode.executeConditionAsBoolean(VirtualFrame, JavaScriptNode)     101.00 |     1       1       1     0     0       0      0 |          0     0      0     0     0       0      0 |
              JSLessThanNodeGen.executeBoolean(VirtualFrame)                           101.00 |     1       1       1     0     0       0      0 |          0     0      0     0     0       0      0 |             10 js:test.js:3:51-58
               JSLessThanNodeGen.executeBoolean_int_int0(VirtualFrame, J)              101.00 |     1       1       1     0     0       0      0 |          0     0      0     0     0       0      0 |
                JSLessThanNode.doInt(I, I)                                             101.00 |     1       1       1     0     0       0      0 |          1     1      1     0     0       0      0 |     59      10 js:test.js:3:51-58
            AbstractRepeatingNode.executeBody(VirtualFrame)                            101.00 |     6      12      12     0     0       0      0 |          0     0      0     0     0       0      0 |              9 js:test.js:3:35-84
             AbstractBlockNode.executeVoid(VirtualFrame)                               101.00 |     6      12      12     0     0       0      0 |          0     0      0     0     0       0      0 |
              AbstractBlockNode.executeVoid(VirtualFrame, JavaScriptNode, I, I)        101.00 |     6      12      12     0     0       0      0 |          0     0      0     0     0       0      0 |             13 js:test.js:3:35-84
               JSWriteCurrentFrameSlotNodeGen.executeVoid(VirtualFrame)                101.00 |     6      12      12     0     0       0      0 |          0     0      0     0     0       0      0 |             14 js:test.js:4:71-79
                JSWriteCurrentFrameSlotNodeGen.executeInt(VirtualFrame)                101.00 |     3       6       6     0     0       0      0 |          0     0      0     0     0       0      0 |             14 js:test.js:4:71-79
                 JSAddNodeGen.executeInt(VirtualFrame)                                 101.00 |     3       6       6     0     0       0      0 |          0     0      0     0     0       0      0 |
                  JSAddNode.doInt(I, I)                                                101.00 |     3       6       6     0     0       0      0 |          0     0      0     0     0       0      0 |
                   Math.addExact(I, I)                                                 100.00 |     3       6       6     0     0       0      0 |          3     6      6     0     0       0      0 |     75      15 js:test.js:4:71-74
                LocalVarPostfixIncNodeGen.executeInt(VirtualFrame)                     101.00 |     3       6       6     0     0       0      0 |          0     0      0     0     0       0      0 |             18 js:test.js:3:60-63
                 LocalVarPostfixIncNode.doInt(Frame)                                   101.00 |     3       6       6     0     0       0      0 |          0     0      0     0     0       0      0 |             18 js:test.js:3:60-63
                  LocalVarIncNode$IncOp.doInt(I)                                       101.00 |     3       6       6     0     0       0      0 |          0     0      0     0     0       0      0 |
                   Math.addExact(I, I)                                                 100.00 |     3       6       6     0     0       0      0 |          3     6      6     0     0       0      0 |     85
       AbstractBlockNode.executeGeneric(VirtualFrame, JavaScriptNode, I, I)              1.00 |     1       8       8     0     0       0      1 |          0     0      0     0     0       0      0 |              2 js:test.js:1:16-100
        ReturnNode$TerminalPositionReturnNode.execute(VirtualFrame)                      1.00 |     1       8       8     0     0       0      1 |          0     0      0     0     0       0      0 |             20 js:test.js:6:87-98
         JSReadCurrentFrameSlotNodeGen.execute(VirtualFrame)                             1.00 |     1       8       8     0     0       0      1 |          0     0      0     0     0       0      0 |
          Integer.valueOf(I)                                                             1.00 |     1       8       8     0     0       0      1 |          1     8      8     0     0       0      1 |    139      21 js:test.js:6:94-97

The --engine.TraceNodeExpansion=truffleTier command prints a tree of all expanded Truffle nodes with statistics after each compilation. This view groups the method expansion tree by node id:

[engine] Expansion tree for test after truffleTier:
Name                                                       Frequency | Count    Size  Cycles   Ifs Loops Invokes Allocs | Self Count  Size Cycles   Ifs Loops Invokes Allocs | IRNode ASTNode Lang:File:Line:Chars
<call-root>                                                     1.00 |    64      72      42     1     1       0      1 |         44    41     18     0     0       0      0 |      0
 FunctionRootNode                                               1.00 |    20      31      24     1     1       0      1 |          3     3      0     0     0       0      0 |     34       0 js:test.js:1:0-100
  FunctionBodyNode                                              1.00 |    17      28      24     1     1       0      1 |          0     0      0     0     0       0      0 |              1 js:test.js:1:0-100
   ExprBlockNode                                                1.00 |    17      28      24     1     1       0      1 |          1     1      0     0     0       0      0 |     50       2 js:test.js:1:16-100
    WhileNode                                                   1.00 |    15      19      16     1     1       0      0 |          0     0      0     0     0       0      0 |              7 js:test.js:3:35-84
     OptimizedOSRLoopNode$OptimizedDefaultOSRLoopNode         101.00 |    15      19      16     1     1       0      0 |          4     3      2     0     1       0      0 |     46       8 js:test.js:3:35-84
      WhileNode$WhileDoRepeatingNode                          101.00 |    11      16      14     1     0       0      0 |          4     3      1     1     0       0      0 |    100       9 js:test.js:3:35-84
       JSLessThanNodeGen                                      101.00 |     1       1       1     0     0       0      0 |          1     1      1     0     0       0      0 |     59      10 js:test.js:3:51-58
       VoidBlockNode                                          101.00 |     6      12      12     0     0       0      0 |          0     0      0     0     0       0      0 |             13 js:test.js:3:35-84
        JSWriteCurrentFrameSlotNodeGen                        101.00 |     6      12      12     0     0       0      0 |          0     0      0     0     0       0      0 |             14 js:test.js:4:71-79
         JSAddNodeGen                                         100.00 |     3       6       6     0     0       0      0 |          3     6      6     0     0       0      0 |     75      15 js:test.js:4:71-74
         LocalVarPostfixIncNodeGen                            100.00 |     3       6       6     0     0       0      0 |          3     6      6     0     0       0      0 |     85      18 js:test.js:3:60-63
    ReturnNode$TerminalPositionReturnNode                       1.00 |     1       8       8     0     0       0      1 |          0     0      0     0     0       0      0 |             20 js:test.js:6:87-98
     JSReadCurrentFrameSlotNodeGen                              1.00 |     1       8       8     0     0       0      1 |          1     8      8     0     0       0      1 |    139      21 js:test.js:6:94-97

The --engine.MethodExpansionStatistics=truffleTier command prints statistics on expanded Java methods during partial evaluation at the end of a run. This can be useful to detect code that produces too many or certain Graal nodes unexpectedly:

[engine] Method expansion statistics after truffleTier:
Name                                                                       Count IR Nodes (min avg max)        Size (min avg max)      Cycles (min avg max)       Ifs  Loops Invokes Allocs | Max IRNode ASTNode Unit:Lang:File:Line:Chars
  <no-source-position>                                                         1      212 (212 212.0 212)       117 (117 117.0 117)         0 (0 0.0 0)             0      0       0      0 |          0         mandelbrot
  OptimizedOSRLoopNode.execute(VirtualFrame)                                   4       13 (0 3.3 5)               9 (0 2.3 3)               6 (0 1.5 2)             0      3       0      0 |        172      60 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:68:2589-2888
  Math.addExact(I, I)                                                          4       12 (3 3.0 3)              24 (6 6.0 6)              24 (6 6.0 6)             0      0       0      0 |        485     103 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:80:2874-2875
  WhileNode$WhileDoRepeatingNode.executeRepeating(VirtualFrame)                4        9 (0 2.3 3)               6 (0 1.5 2)               3 (0 0.8 1)             3      0       0      0 |         88      17 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:57:2374-3431
  JSTypes.intToDouble(I)                                                       7        7 (1 1.0 1)               7 (1 1.0 1)              24 (0 3.4 8)             0      0       0      0 |        144      41 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:62:2478-2486
  OptimizedCallTarget.castArgumentsImpl(Object, Class)                         1        7 (7 7.0 7)              25 (25 25.0 25)           24 (24 24.0 24)          0      0       0      0 |         12         mandelbrot
  JSWriteCurrentFrameSlotNodeGen.executeVoid(VirtualFrame)                     6        6 (0 1.0 3)               4 (0 0.7 2)               2 (0 0.3 1)             2      0       0      0 |        563      46 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:64:2519-2544
  AbstractBlockNode.executeVoid(VirtualFrame, JavaScriptNode, I, I)            8        6 (0 0.8 4)               6 (0 0.8 4)               0 (0 0.0 0)             0      0       0      0 |        177      39 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:61:2459-3416
  Math.multiplyExact(I, I)                                                     4        6 (1 1.5 2)              12 (2 3.0 4)              20 (4 5.0 6)             0      0       0      0 |        155      49 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:64:2529-2534
  OptimizedCallTarget.injectArgumentsProfile(Object)                           1        4 (4 4.0 4)               3 (3 3.0 3)               0 (0 0.0 0)             0      0       0      0 |          5         mandelbrot
  JSMultiplyNode.doDouble(D, D)                                                4        4 (1 1.0 1)               4 (1 1.0 1)               8 (2 2.0 2)             0      0       0      0 |        280      75 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:70:2657-2663
  IfNode.executeVoid(VirtualFrame)                                             3        3 (0 1.0 3)               2 (0 0.7 2)               1 (0 0.3 1)             1      0       0      0 |        606     126 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:93:3240-3397
  Math.subtractExact(I, I)                                                     1        3 (3 3.0 3)               6 (6 6.0 6)               6 (6 6.0 6)             0      0       0      0 |        589     129 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:93:3249-3257
  JSSubtractNode.doDouble(D, D)                                                3        3 (1 1.0 1)               3 (1 1.0 1)               3 (1 1.0 1)             0      0       0      0 |        167      47 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:64:2528-2544
  JSLessThanNode.doInt(I, I)                                                   3        3 (1 1.0 1)               3 (1 1.0 1)               3 (1 1.0 1)             0      0       0      0 |        187      62 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:68:2596-2602
  JSAddNode.doDouble(D, D)                                                     3        3 (1 1.0 1)               3 (1 1.0 1)               3 (1 1.0 1)             0      0       0      0 |        263      67 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:69:2623-2639
  JSDivideNode.doDouble(D, D)                                                  2        2 (1 1.0 1)               2 (1 1.0 1)              64 (32 32.0 32)          0      0       0      0 |        165      48 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:64:2528-2540
  JSBitwiseXorNode.doInteger(I, I)                                             2        2 (1 1.0 1)               2 (1 1.0 1)               2 (1 1.0 1)             0      0       0      0 |        575     119 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:90:3170-3173
  JSEqualNode.doInt(I, I)                                                      2        2 (1 1.0 1)               2 (1 1.0 1)               2 (1 1.0 1)             0      0       0      0 |        592     127 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:93:3244-3257
  RepeatingNode.executeRepeatingWithValue(VirtualFrame)                        4        1 (0 0.3 1)               1 (0 0.3 1)               0 (0 0.0 0)             0      0       0      0 |        499      61 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:68:2589-2888
  FunctionRootNode.executeInRealm(VirtualFrame)                                1        1 (1 1.0 1)               1 (1 1.0 1)               0 (0 0.0 0)             0      0       0      0 |         53       0 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:50:2279-3447
  OptimizedCallTarget.profiledPERoot(Object)                                   1        1 (1 1.0 1)               2 (2 2.0 2)               2 (2 2.0 2)             0      0       0      0 |        737         mandelbrot
  PolyglotReferences$WeakSingleContext.get()                                   1        1 (1 1.0 1)               1 (1 1.0 1)               0 (0 0.0 0)             0      0       0      0 |         41         mandelbrot
  JSLeftShiftNode.doInteger(I, I)                                              1        1 (1 1.0 1)               1 (1 1.0 1)               1 (1 1.0 1)             0      0       0      0 |        619     134 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:94:3269-3277
  Integer.intValue()                                                           1        1 (1 1.0 1)               2 (2 2.0 2)               2 (2 2.0 2)             0      0       0      0 |         50       4 mandelbrot:js:1:0-0
  JSSubtractNode.doInt(I, I)                                                   2        1 (0 0.5 1)               1 (0 0.5 1)               1 (0 0.5 1)             0      0       0      0 |        940     136 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:94:3282-3295
  JSLeftShiftConstantNode.doInteger(I)                                         1        1 (1 1.0 1)               1 (1 1.0 1)               1 (1 1.0 1)             0      0       0      0 |        527     107 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:83:2907-2922
  JSSubtractNodeGen.executeDouble(VirtualFrame)                                3        1 (0 0.3 1)               1 (0 0.3 1)               0 (0 0.0 0)             0      0       0      0 |         33      47 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:64:2528-2544
  JSReadCurrentFrameSlotNodeGen.executeInt(VirtualFrame)                       1        1 (1 1.0 1)               1 (1 1.0 1)               0 (0 0.0 0)             0      0       0      0 |         74      19 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:57:2381-2382
  Integer.valueOf(I)                                                           1        1 (1 1.0 1)               8 (8 8.0 8)               8 (8 8.0 8)             0      0       0      1 |        939     154 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:105:3442-3445
  JSBitwiseOrNode.doInteger(I, I)                                              1        1 (1 1.0 1)               1 (1 1.0 1)               1 (1 1.0 1)             0      0       0      0 |        532     106 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:83:2907-2931
  JSGreaterThanNode.doDouble(D, D)                                             1        1 (1 1.0 1)               1 (1 1.0 1)               2 (2 2.0 2)             0      0       0      0 |        461      93 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:76:2800-2815
  OptimizedCallTarget.unsafeCast(Object, Class, Z, Z, Z)                       1        1 (1 1.0 1)               0 (0 0.0 0)               0 (0 0.0 0)             0      0       0      0 |         10         mandelbrot
  JavaScriptRealmBoundaryRootNode.execute(VirtualFrame)                        1        1 (1 1.0 1)               1 (1 1.0 1)               0 (0 0.0 0)             0      0       0      0 |         38         mandelbrot
  JSLeftShiftConstantNodeGen.executeInt(VirtualFrame)                          1        1 (1 1.0 1)               1 (1 1.0 1)               0 (0 0.0 0)             0      0       0      0 |         36     107 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:83:2907-2922
  DualNode.execute(VirtualFrame)                                               1        0 (0 0.0 0)               0 (0 0.0 0)               0 (0 0.0 0)             0      0       0      0 |                  2 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:50:2279-3447
  ...

The --engine.NodeExpansionStatistics=truffleTier command prints statistics on expanded Truffle nodes during partial evaluation at the end of a run. This can be useful to detect code that produces too many or certain Graal nodes unexpectedly. It also shows individual specialization combinations as they were observed during compilation:

[engine] Node expansion statistics after truffleTier:
Name                                                    Count IR Nodes (min avg max)        Size (min avg max)      Cycles (min avg max)       Ifs  Loops Invokes Allocs | Max IRNode ASTNode Unit:Lang:File:Line:Chars
  <call-root>                                               1      226 (226 226.0 226)       148 (148 148.0 148)        26 (26 26.0 26)          0      0       0      0 |          0         mandelbrot
  OptimizedOSRLoopNode$OptimizedDefaultOSRLoopNode          4       13 (0 3.3 5)               9 (0 2.3 3)               6 (0 1.5 2)             0      3       0      0 |        172      60 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:68:2589-2888
  JSAddConstantRightNumberNodeGen                           4       12 (3 3.0 3)              24 (6 6.0 6)              24 (6 6.0 6)             0      0       0      0 |        485     103 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:80:2874-2875
    [doInt(I)]                                              4       12 (3 3.0 3)              24 (6 6.0 6)              24 (6 6.0 6)             0      0       0      0 |        485     103 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:80:2874-2875
  JSMultiplyNodeGen                                         6       11 (1 1.8 3)              17 (1 2.8 6)              28 (2 4.7 10)            0      0       0      0 |        155      49 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:64:2529-2534
    [doIntALargerZero(I, I), doIntBLargerZero(I, I)]        2        6 (3 3.0 3)              12 (6 6.0 6)              20 (10 10.0 10)          0      0       0      0 |        155      49 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:64:2529-2534
    [doDouble(D, D)]                                        4        5 (1 1.3 2)               5 (1 1.3 2)               8 (2 2.0 2)             0      0       0      0 |        275      75 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:70:2657-2663
  WhileNode$WhileDoRepeatingNode                            4       10 (0 2.5 4)               7 (0 1.8 3)               3 (0 0.8 1)             3      0       0      0 |        499      61 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:68:2589-2888
  JSSubtractNodeGen                                         5        9 (1 1.8 3)              12 (1 2.4 6)              10 (1 2.0 6)             0      0       0      0 |        589     129 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:93:3249-3257
    [doDouble(D, D)]                                        3        5 (1 1.7 2)               5 (1 1.7 2)               3 (1 1.0 1)             0      0       0      0 |         33      47 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:64:2528-2544
    [doInt(I, I)]                                           2        4 (1 2.0 3)               7 (1 3.5 6)               7 (1 3.5 6)             0      0       0      0 |        589     129 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:93:3249-3257
  JSWriteCurrentFrameSlotNodeGen                           18        7 (0 0.4 3)               5 (0 0.3 2)               2 (0 0.1 1)             2      0       0      0 |        563      46 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:64:2519-2544
  JSDivideNodeGen                                           2        5 (2 2.5 3)               5 (2 2.5 3)              88 (40 44.0 48)          0      0       0      0 |        158      48 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:64:2528-2540
    [doDouble(D, D)]                                        2        5 (2 2.5 3)               5 (2 2.5 3)              88 (40 44.0 48)          0      0       0      0 |        158      48 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:64:2528-2540
  VoidBlockNode                                             7        5 (0 0.7 4)               5 (0 0.7 4)               0 (0 0.0 0)             0      0       0      0 |        177      39 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:61:2459-3416
  JSAddNodeGen                                              3        3 (1 1.0 1)               3 (1 1.0 1)               3 (1 1.0 1)             0      0       0      0 |        263      67 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:69:2623-2639
    [doDouble(D, D)]                                        3        3 (1 1.0 1)               3 (1 1.0 1)               3 (1 1.0 1)             0      0       0      0 |        263      67 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:69:2623-2639
  JSLessThanNodeGen                                         3        3 (1 1.0 1)               3 (1 1.0 1)               3 (1 1.0 1)             0      0       0      0 |        187      62 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:68:2596-2602
    [doInt(I, I)]                                           3        3 (1 1.0 1)               3 (1 1.0 1)               3 (1 1.0 1)             0      0       0      0 |        187      62 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:68:2596-2602
  IfNode                                                    4        3 (0 0.8 3)               2 (0 0.5 2)               1 (0 0.3 1)             1      0       0      0 |        606     126 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:93:3240-3397
  JSGreaterThanNodeGen                                      1        2 (2 2.0 2)               2 (2 2.0 2)               2 (2 2.0 2)             0      0       0      0 |        460      93 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:76:2800-2815
    [doDouble(D, D)]                                        1        2 (2 2.0 2)               2 (2 2.0 2)               2 (2 2.0 2)             0      0       0      0 |        460      93 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:76:2800-2815
  JSBitwiseXorNodeGen                                       2        2 (1 1.0 1)               2 (1 1.0 1)               2 (1 1.0 1)             0      0       0      0 |        575     119 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:90:3170-3173
    [doInteger(I, I)]                                       2        2 (1 1.0 1)               2 (1 1.0 1)               2 (1 1.0 1)             0      0       0      0 |        575     119 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:90:3170-3173
  JSLeftShiftConstantNodeGen                                1        2 (2 2.0 2)               2 (2 2.0 2)               1 (1 1.0 1)             0      0       0      0 |         36     107 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:83:2907-2922
    [doInteger(I)]                                          1        2 (2 2.0 2)               2 (2 2.0 2)               1 (1 1.0 1)             0      0       0      0 |         36     107 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:83:2907-2922
  JSReadCurrentFrameSlotNodeGen                             2        2 (1 1.0 1)               9 (1 4.5 8)               8 (0 4.0 8)             0      0       0      1 |         74      19 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:57:2381-2382
  JSEqualNodeGen                                            2        2 (1 1.0 1)               2 (1 1.0 1)               2 (1 1.0 1)             0      0       0      0 |        592     127 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:93:3244-3257
    [doInt(I, I)]                                           2        2 (1 1.0 1)               2 (1 1.0 1)               2 (1 1.0 1)             0      0       0      0 |        592     127 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:93:3244-3257
  FunctionRootNode                                          1        2 (2 2.0 2)               2 (2 2.0 2)               0 (0 0.0 0)             0      0       0      0 |         53       0 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:50:2279-3447
  ExprBlockNode                                             1        1 (1 1.0 1)               1 (1 1.0 1)               0 (0 0.0 0)             0      0       0      0 |         69       5 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:50:2305-3447
  JSBitwiseOrNodeGen                                        1        1 (1 1.0 1)               1 (1 1.0 1)               1 (1 1.0 1)             0      0       0      0 |        532     106 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:83:2907-2931
    [doInteger(I, I)]                                       1        1 (1 1.0 1)               1 (1 1.0 1)               1 (1 1.0 1)             0      0       0      0 |        532     106 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:83:2907-2931
  AccessIndexedArgumentNode                                 1        1 (1 1.0 1)               2 (2 2.0 2)               2 (2 2.0 2)             0      0       0      0 |         50       4 mandelbrot:js:1:0-0
  JSLeftShiftNodeGen                                        2        1 (0 0.5 1)               1 (0 0.5 1)               1 (0 0.5 1)             0      0       0      0 |        619     134 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:94:3269-3277
    [doInteger(I, I)]                                       1        1 (1 1.0 1)               1 (1 1.0 1)               1 (1 1.0 1)             0      0       0      0 |        619     134 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:94:3269-3277
    <unknown>                                               1        0 (0 0.0 0)               0 (0 0.0 0)               0 (0 0.0 0)             0      0       0      0 |                134 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:94:3269-3277
  FunctionBodyNode                                          1        0 (0 0.0 0)               0 (0 0.0 0)               0 (0 0.0 0)             0      0       0      0 |                  1 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:50:2279-3447
  ReturnNode$TerminalPositionReturnNode                     1        0 (0 0.0 0)               0 (0 0.0 0)               0 (0 0.0 0)             0      0       0      0 |                153 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:105:3435-3445
  DualNode                                                  1        0 (0 0.0 0)               0 (0 0.0 0)               0 (0 0.0 0)             0      0       0      0 |                  2 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:50:2279-3447
  WhileNode                                                 4        0 (0 0.0 0)               0 (0 0.0 0)               0 (0 0.0 0)             0      0       0      0 |                 15 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:57:2374-3431
  DirectBreakTargetNode                                     2        0 (0 0.0 0)               0 (0 0.0 0)               0 (0 0.0 0)             0      0       0      0 |                 14 mandelbrot:js:mandelbrot.js:50:2305-3447

The --engine.InstrumentBoundaries command prints, at the end of the process, information about runtime calls (@TruffleBoundary) made from compiled code. These cause objects to escape (are black-boxes to further optimization) and should generally be minimized. Also see the Branch Instrumentation guide for more details about instrumenting branches and boundaries.

Execution profile (sorted by hotness)
=====================================
  0: *******************************************************************************
  1:

com.oracle.truffle.js.nodes.binary.JSAddNode.doStringInt(JSAddNode.java:177) [bci: 2]
[0] count = 22525269

com.oracle.truffle.js.builtins.ConstructorBuiltins$ConstructDateNode.constructDateZero(ConstructorBuiltins.java:837) [bci: 6]
[1] count = 69510

The --engine.InstrumentBranches command prints, at the end of the process, information of branch usage in compiled code:

Execution profile (sorted by hotness)
=====================================
  2: ***************
  1: **************
  5: *************
  4: ************
  3: *********
 10: **
  8: *
  9: *
 14: *
 ...

com.oracle.truffle.js.nodes.access.PropertyGetNode.getValueOrDefault(PropertyGetNode.java:301) [bci: 55]
[2] state = BOTH(if=36486564#, else=44603498#)

com.oracle.truffle.js.nodes.control.IfNode.execute(IfNode.java:158) [bci: 12]
[1] state = BOTH(if=72572593#, else=1305851#)

com.oracle.truffle.js.nodes.function.JSFunctionCallNode.executeCall(JSFunctionCallNode.java:233) [bci: 18]
[5] state = BOTH(if=38703322#, else=32550439#)

com.oracle.truffle.js.nodes.access.PropertyCacheNode$PrototypeShapeCheckNode.accept(PropertyCacheNode.java:364) [bci: 4]
[4] state = ELSE(if=0#, else=64094316#)

com.oracle.truffle.js.nodes.control.WhileNode$WhileDoRepeatingNode.executeRepeating(WhileNode.java:230) [bci: 5]
[3] state = BOTH(if=44392142#, else=7096299#)
...

The --engine.SpecializationStatistics command prints detailed histograms about Node classes and their usage of Truffle DSL specializations. See Specialization Statistics for a tutorial on how to use it.

Note: Specialization statistics require a recompilation of the interpeter.

 -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
| Name                                                                         Instances          Executions     Executions per instance
 -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
| JSWriteCurrentFrameSlotNodeGen                                               8 (17%)            18 (12%)        Min=         1 Avg=        2.25 Max=          5  MaxNode= test.js~5-7:76-128
|   doBoolean <boolean>                                                          1 (13%)             1 (6%)         Min=         1 Avg=        1.00 Max=          1  MaxNode= test.js~4:52-71
|   doInt <int>                                                                  1 (13%)             1 (6%)         Min=         1 Avg=        1.00 Max=          1  MaxNode= test.js~5-7:76-128
|   doSafeIntegerInt                                                             0 (0%)              0 (0%)         Min=         0 Avg=        0.00 Max=          0  MaxNode=  -
|   doSafeInteger                                                                0 (0%)              0 (0%)         Min=         0 Avg=        0.00 Max=          0  MaxNode=  -
|   doLong                                                                       0 (0%)              0 (0%)         Min=         0 Avg=        0.00 Max=          0  MaxNode=  -
|   doDouble                                                                     0 (0%)              0 (0%)         Min=         0 Avg=        0.00 Max=          0  MaxNode=  -
|   doObject                                                                     7 (88%)            16 (89%)        Min=         1 Avg=        2.29 Max=          5  MaxNode= test.js~5-7:76-128
|     <DynamicObjectBasic>                                                         6 (86%)            12 (75%)        Min=         1 Avg=        2.00 Max=          5  MaxNode= test.js~5-7:76-128
|     <IteratorRecord>                                                             1 (14%)             1 (6%)         Min=         1 Avg=        1.00 Max=          1  MaxNode= test.js~1-8:16-130
|     <String>                                                                     2 (29%)             2 (13%)        Min=         1 Avg=        1.00 Max=          1  MaxNode= test.js~5-7:76-128
|     <Integer>                                                                    1 (14%)             1 (6%)         Min=         1 Avg=        1.00 Max=          1  MaxNode= test.js~6:105-123
|   --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|   [doBoolean]                                                                  1 (13%)             1 (6%)         Min=         1 Avg=        1.00 Max=          1  MaxNode= test.js~4:52-71
|   [doInt, doObject]                                                            1 (13%)             4 (22%)        Min=         4 Avg=        4.00 Max=          4  MaxNode= test.js~5-7:76-128
|     doInt                                                                        1 (100%)            1 (25%)        Min=         1 Avg=        1.00 Max=          1  MaxNode= test.js~5-7:76-128
|     doObject                                                                     1 (100%)            3 (75%)        Min=         3 Avg=        3.00 Max=          3  MaxNode= test.js~5-7:76-128
|   [doObject]                                                                   6 (75%)            13 (72%)        Min=         1 Avg=        2.17 Max=          5  MaxNode= test.js~5-7:76-128
 -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
| Name                                                                         Instances          Executions     Executions per instance
 -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
| JSReadCurrentFrameSlotNodeGen                                                8 (17%)            25 (17%)        Min=         1 Avg=        3.13 Max=          5  MaxNode= test.js~5-7:76-128
|   doBoolean                                                                    0 (0%)              0 (0%)         Min=         0 Avg=        0.00 Max=          0  MaxNode=  -
|   doInt <no-args>                                                              1 (13%)             1 (4%)         Min=         1 Avg=        1.00 Max=          1  MaxNode= test.js~5:81-87
|   doDouble                                                                     0 (0%)              0 (0%)         Min=         0 Avg=        0.00 Max=          0  MaxNode=  -
|   doObject <no-args>                                                           8 (100%)           24 (96%)        Min=         1 Avg=        3.00 Max=          5  MaxNode= test.js~5-7:76-128
|   doSafeInteger                                                                0 (0%)              0 (0%)         Min=         0 Avg=        0.00 Max=          0  MaxNode=  -
|   --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|   [doInt, doObject]                                                            1 (13%)             4 (16%)        Min=         4 Avg=        4.00 Max=          4  MaxNode= test.js~5:81-87
|     doInt                                                                        1 (100%)            1 (25%)        Min=         1 Avg=        1.00 Max=          1  MaxNode= test.js~5:81-87
|     doObject                                                                     1 (100%)            3 (75%)        Min=         3 Avg=        3.00 Max=          3  MaxNode= test.js~5:81-87
|   [doObject]                                                                   7 (88%)            21 (84%)        Min=         1 Avg=        3.00 Max=          5  MaxNode= test.js~5-7:76-128
 -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Controlling What Is Compiled #

To make the best use of the former options, limit what is compiled to the methods that you are interested in.

  • --engine.CompileOnly=foo restricts compilation to methods with foo in their name. Use this in combination with returning a value or taking parameters to avoid code being compiled away.

  • --engine.CompileImmediately compiles methods as soon as they are run.

  • --engine.BackgroundCompilation=false compiles synchronously, which can simplify things.

  • --engine.Inlining=false disables inlining which can make code easier to understand.

  • --engine.OSR=false disables on-stack-replacement (compilation of the bodies of while loops for example) which can make code easier to understand.

  • --engine.Compilation=false turns off Truffle compilation all together.

Debugging Deoptimizations #

Sometimes compiled code deoptimizes (goes from Truffle compiled code back to the interpreter) unexpectedly. These are some ways to investigate why the code is deoptimized. It is very important for performance to avoid repeated deoptimizations.

The --engine.TraceCompilation option shows deoptimizations with an [engine] opt deopt prefix, which is useful to evaluate if many deoptimizations happen. However, it shows no other details.

Materializing a frame with FrameInstance#getFrame(READ_WRITE|MATERIALIZE) from the stack causes deoptimizations (but no invalidation). These deoptimizations can be traced with --engine.TraceDeoptimizeFrame.

When using native images, you need to build the native image with -H:+IncludeNodeSourcePositions to enable stack traces for deoptimizations. These are disabled by default to save on image size.

On natives images, --engine.TraceTransferToInterpreter prints an accurate stack trace for any deoptimization, it is effectively the same as --vm.XX:+TraceDeoptimization --engine.NodeSourcePositions. This is often the most efficient way to find where a deoptimization comes from thanks to the stracktrace.

[Deoptimization initiated
    name: String#[]
    sp: 0x7ffd7b992710  ip: 0x7f26a8d8079f
    reason: TransferToInterpreter  action: InvalidateReprofile
    debugId: 25  speculation: jdk.vm.ci.meta.SpeculationLog$NoSpeculationReason@13dbed9e
    stack trace that triggered deoptimization:
        at org.truffleruby.core.string.StringNodesFactory$StringSubstringPrimitiveNodeFactory$StringSubstringPrimitiveNodeGen.execute(StringNodesFactory.java:12760)
        at org.truffleruby.core.string.StringNodes$GetIndexNode.substring(StringNodes.java:836)
        at org.truffleruby.core.string.StringNodes$GetIndexNode.getIndex(StringNodes.java:650)
        at org.truffleruby.core.string.StringNodesFactory$GetIndexNodeFactory$GetIndexNodeGen.execute(StringNodesFactory.java:1435)
        at org.truffleruby.language.RubyCoreMethodRootNode.execute(RubyCoreMethodRootNode.java:53)
        at org.graalvm.compiler.truffle.runtime.OptimizedCallTarget.executeRootNode(OptimizedCallTarget.java:632)
        at org.graalvm.compiler.truffle.runtime.OptimizedCallTarget.profiledPERoot(OptimizedCallTarget.java:603)
[Deoptimization of frame
    name: String#[]
    sp: 0x7ffd7b992710  ip: 0x7f26a8d8079f
    stack trace where execution continues:
        at org.truffleruby.core.string.StringNodesFactory$StringSubstringPrimitiveNodeFactory$StringSubstringPrimitiveNodeGen.execute(StringNodesFactory.java:12760) bci 99  return address 0x4199a1d
        at org.truffleruby.core.string.StringNodes$GetIndexNode.substring(StringNodes.java:836) bci 32 duringCall  return address 0x41608e0
        at org.truffleruby.core.string.StringNodes$GetIndexNode.getIndex(StringNodes.java:650) bci 25 duringCall  return address 0x415f197
        at org.truffleruby.core.string.StringNodesFactory$GetIndexNodeFactory$GetIndexNodeGen.execute(StringNodesFactory.java:1435) bci 109 duringCall  return address 0x4182391
        at org.truffleruby.language.RubyCoreMethodRootNode.execute(RubyCoreMethodRootNode.java:53) bci 14 duringCall  return address 0x4239a29
        at org.graalvm.compiler.truffle.runtime.OptimizedCallTarget.executeRootNode(OptimizedCallTarget.java:632) bci 9 duringCall  return address 0x3f1c4c9
        at org.graalvm.compiler.truffle.runtime.OptimizedCallTarget.profiledPERoot(OptimizedCallTarget.java:603) bci 37 duringCall  return address 0x3f1d965
]
]

On HotSpot, --engine.TraceTransferToInterpreter prints a stack trace only for explicit deoptimizations via CompilerDirectives.transferToInterpreterAndInvalidate() or CompilerDirectives.transferToInterpreter(). The reported location can be incorrect if the deoptimization was caused by something else. In that case it will report the stracktrace of the next CompilerDirectives.transferToInterpreter* call even though it is not the cause.

[engine] transferToInterpreter at
  BinaryConstraint.output(../../../../4dev/js-benchmarks/octane-deltablue.js:416)
    Constraint.satisfy(../../../../4dev/js-benchmarks/octane-deltablue.js:183)
    Planner.incrementalAdd(../../../../4dev/js-benchmarks/octane-deltablue.js:597) <split-609bcfb6>
    Constraint.addConstraint(../../../../4dev/js-benchmarks/octane-deltablue.js:165) <split-7d94beb9>
    UnaryConstraint(../../../../4dev/js-benchmarks/octane-deltablue.js:219) <split-560348e6>
    Function.prototype.call(<builtin>:1) <split-1df8b5b8>
    EditConstraint(../../../../4dev/js-benchmarks/octane-deltablue.js:315) <split-23202fce>
    ...
  com.oracle.truffle.api.CompilerDirectives.transferToInterpreterAndInvalidate(CompilerDirectives.java:90)
    com.oracle.truffle.js.nodes.access.PropertyCacheNode.deoptimize(PropertyCacheNode.java:1269)
    com.oracle.truffle.js.nodes.access.PropertyGetNode.getValueOrDefault(PropertyGetNode.java:305)
    com.oracle.truffle.js.nodes.access.PropertyGetNode.getValueOrUndefined(PropertyGetNode.java:191)
    com.oracle.truffle.js.nodes.access.PropertyNode.executeWithTarget(PropertyNode.java:153)
    com.oracle.truffle.js.nodes.access.PropertyNode.execute(PropertyNode.java:140)
    ...

On HotSpot, --vm.XX:+UnlockDiagnosticVMOptions --vm.XX:+DebugNonSafepoints --vm.XX:+TraceDeoptimization prints all deoptimization events (but no stacktraces), whether the code is compiled by Truffle or conventional compilers. The TraceDeoptimization option might require using a fastdebug JDK.

Uncommon trap   bci=9 pc=0x00000001097f2235, relative_pc=501, method=com.oracle.truffle.js.nodes.access.PropertyNode.executeInt(Ljava/lang/Object;Ljava/lang/Object;)I, debug_id=0
Uncommon trap occurred in org.graalvm.compiler.truffle.runtime.OptimizedCallTarget::profiledPERoot compiler=JVMCI compile_id=2686 (JVMCI: installed code name=BinaryConstraint.output#2)  (@0x00000001097f2235) thread=5891 reason=transfer_to_interpreter action=reinterpret unloaded_class_index=-1 debug_id=0

Finally, on native images, --vm.XX:+TraceDeoptimizationDetails prints additional information:

[Deoptimization initiated
    name: BinaryConstraint.output
    sp: 0x7ffee7324d90  ip: 0x1126c51a8
    reason: TransferToInterpreter  action: InvalidateReprofile
    debugId: 3  speculation: jdk.vm.ci.meta.SpeculationLog$NoSpeculationReason@10f942aa0
[Deoptimization of frame
    name: BinaryConstraint.output
    sp: 0x7ffee7324d90  ip: 0x1126c51a8
    stack trace where execution continues:
        at org.graalvm.compiler.truffle.runtime.OptimizedCallTarget.profiledPERoot(OptimizedCallTarget.java:475) bci 0  return address 0x10aab9e5e
            org.graalvm.compiler.truffle.runtime.OptimizedCallTarget.profiledPERoot(OptimizedCallTarget.java:475)
            bci: 0  deoptMethodOffset: 35524160  deoptMethod: 0x10aab9e40  return address: 0x10aab9e5e  offset: 0
            slot 0  kind: Object  value: com.oracle.svm.truffle.api.SubstrateOptimizedCallTarget@0x112cbbaa0  offset: 64
            slot 1  kind: Object  value: [Ljava.lang.Object;@0x1144a7db0  offset: 56
]
]

You might notice the presence of a debugId or debug_id in the output of these options. This id might only be set if you also enable dumping, e.g., via --vm.Dgraal.Dump=Truffle:1 (see below). In that case, the debug id will correspond to the id of a node in the IGV graph. First, open the first phase of the relevant compilation. That id can be searched via id=NUMBER in IGV’s Search in Nodes search box, then selecting Open Search for node NUMBER in Node Searches window, and then clicking the Search in following phases button.

Debugging Invalidations #

Invalidations happen when a compiled CallTarget is thrown away.

The most common causes are:

  • An explicit CompilerDirectives.transferToInterpreterAndInvalidate() (an internal invalidation)
  • One of the Assumption used by that CallTarget has been invalidated (an external invalidation). Use --engine.TraceAssumptions to trace those with more details.

The --engine.TraceCompilation option also shows CallTarget invalidations with an [engine] opt inv. prefix.

Ideal Graph Visualizer #

The Ideal Graph Visualizer (IGV) is a tool to understand Truffle ASTs and the Graal Compiler graphs.

A typical usage is to run with --vm.Dgraal.Dump=Truffle:1 --vm.Dgraal.PrintGraph=Network, which will show you Truffle ASTs, guest-language call graphs, and the Graal graphs as they leave the Truffle phase. If the -Dgraal.PrintGraph=Network flag is omitted then the dump files are placed in the graal_dumps directory, which you should then open in IGV.

Use --vm.Dgraal.Dump=Truffle:2 to dump Graal graphs between each compiler phase.

C1 Visualizer #

The C1 Visualizer is a tool to understand the Low Level IR (LIR), register allocation, and code generation stages of GraalVM. It is available here.

A typical usage is --vm.Dgraal.Dump=:3. Files are put into a graal_dumps directory which you should then open in the C1 Visualizer.

Disassembler #

THe --vm.XX:+UnlockDiagnosticVMOptions --vm.XX:+PrintAssembly commands combination prints assembly code. You will need to install hsdis using mx hsdis in graal/compiler, or manually install it into the current directory from here.

Typical usage is --vm.Dgraal.Dump --vm.Dgraal.PrintBackendCFG=true. Files are put into a graal_dumps directory which you should then open in the C1 Visualizer.

Combine with --vm.XX:TieredStopAtLevel=0 to disable compilation of runtime routines so that it’s easier to find your guest-language method.

Note: You can also look at assembly code in the C1 Visualizer.

These have been the most common and powerful ways to optimize or debug Truffle interpreters.

Connect with us